Coalition Sues EPA for Failing to Address Factory Farm Air Pollution

January 28, 2015

Environmental, humane and community organizations seek action to protect public health, animals, and the environment

WASHINGTON, D.C. (Jan. 28) – A coalition of environmental, humane and community organizations filed two lawsuits against Environmental Protection Agency today for failing to address air pollution from factory farms. The pollution contributes to significant human health problems, including asthma and heart attacks; endangers animal health; intensifies the effects of climate change; and causes regional haze and “dead zones” in waterways.

Across the U.S., an estimated 20,000 factory farms confine billions of chickens, hogs and other animals and emit noxious air pollutants, including ammonia, hydrogen sulfide, volatile organic compounds, methane and particulate matter.

The Environmental Integrity Project and the Humane Society of the United States filed the lawsuits in federal court on behalf of rural residents and family farmers whose health and quality of life is affected by noxious air pollutants from factory farms.

“When the emissions are at their worst, we have had to leave our home for days at a time,” said Rosie Partridge, a rural resident of  Sac County, Iowa, whose home is surrounded by more than 30,000 hogs within four miles. “The ammonia and hydrogen sulfide are so strong that my husband has trouble breathing.”

The lawsuits seek to prompt EPA to take action on two rulemaking petitions. Those petitions, filed years previously, asked EPA to use its authority under the federal Clean Air Act to control emissions of air pollution from factory farms.

“Factory farm air pollution harms public health, the environment and rural quality of life,” said Tarah Heinzen, attorney for the Environmental Integrity Project. “Yet EPA is looking the other way while citizen pleas for action collect dust on the agency’s shelf. EPA has acknowledged the harmful impacts of factory farm air pollution for over a decade, yet is still failing to act on the problem.”

Jonathan Lovvorn, chief counsel for animal protection litigation for The Humane Society of the United States, said: “Animal factories subject millions of animals and farm workers to highly toxic levels of air pollution on the farm, and also release huge amounts of these toxins into the environment. EPA’s failure to address these impacts should be alarming to anyone that cares about animal welfare, worker safety, human health, environmental protection or the preservation of rural communities.”

“In California’s San Joaquin Valley, we have suffered a huge increase in factory farm dairies over the past decade,” said Tom Frantz, a farmer and President of the Association of Irritated Residents (AIR).  “Ammonia emissions from factory farm dairies are causing the highest fine particulate matter levels in the United States, which seriously harms our health while EPA has done nothing.”

Background: The two organizations filed petitions with EPA in 2009 and 2011 asking the agency to address factory farm pollution, but the agency failed to act. The legal basis for the lawsuits filed today is that EPA’s delays of nearly six and four years in responding to the petitions is unreasonable under federal law.

The petition from the Humane Society of the United States requests that EPA list factory farms as  a category of sources of pollution under the Clean Air Act, and set performance standards for new and existing facilities. The Environmental Integrity Project’s petition asks EPA to set health-based standards for ammonia. The lawsuits ask the court to order EPA to make a final decision on the 2011 and 2009 petitions within 90 days.

The plaintiffs are the Environmental Integrity Project, the Humane Society of the United States, Center for Food Safety, Sierra Club, Friends of the Earth, Clean Wisconsin, Iowa Citizens for Community Improvement, and the Association of Irritated Residents (represented by the Center on Race, Poverty & the Environment).

Dr. Keeve Nachman, an assistant professor at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health’s Center for a Livable Future, said: “There is mounting evidence that air pollutants from large-scale animal operations can make nearby residents sick. It’s important that EPA use its authority to protect those most vulnerable to the effects of these exposures.”

FACTS:

1) U.S. factory farms produce more than 500 million tons of manure every year, more than three times the waste produced by humans, according to EPA.  Instead of treating the feces and urine, many factory farms store it in huge pits that release odors and air pollution and sometimes spill, contaminating rivers. Operators also spray manure onto fields, sending bacteria-laden droplets onto the homes of downwind residents.

2) The federal Clean Air Act has been in effect for nearly 45 years, but EPA has failed to use its authority to protect public health from factory farms that have proliferated across the U.S.

3) Livestock are responsible for 34 percent of U.S. methane emissions (the nation’s second most prevalent greenhouse gas), and methane has more than 20 times the climate change impact of carbon dioxide, according to EPA.

4) Animal agriculture is the nation’s leading source of ammonia emissions, which can cause nasal, throat and eye irritation, coughs, dizziness and other health problems. Poultry operations in the top ten biggest chicken producing states release at least 700 million tons of ammonia every year. 5) Large dairy and swine animal feeding operations emit 100,000 pounds of hydrogen sulfide annually, according to an EPA estimate. Hydrogen sulfide causes extreme odors and contributes to acid rain and regional haze.

MEDIA CONTACTS:

For a copy of the lawsuit against EPA for ammonia air pollution, click here.

For a copy of the lawsuit against EPA for methane and other air pollutants, click here.

For a fact sheet on air pollution from factory farms, click here.

For quotes about air pollution from factory farms, click here.

For a copy of the 2011 petition to EPA by the Environmental Integrity Project and allies about air pollution that was the basis for one of the lawsuits filed today, click here.

For a copy of the 2009 petition to EPA by the Humane Society of the United States and allies that was the basis for the other lawsuit filed today, click here.